Biblioteca della Libertà

Categoria/Category: Anno LI, n. 216, maggio-agosto 2016
Editore/Publisher: Centro Einaudi
Anno/Year: 2016
Articolo completo/Full text: BDL_216_Burelli.pdf


The question that I address in this paper is what makes a political theory realistic.
Political realism’s dissatisfaction with moralistic liberal theories cannot be reduced to methodological worries of the sort that concern non-ideal theorists; rather, it involves a different theoretical background. In this paper, I unpack the specific conception of politics that distinguishes political realism from liberal moralism. 
Drawing on Waldron’s account of the circumstances of politics, I argue that politics emerges from the interplay between conflict and order. I provide an analysis of conflict as distinct from pluralism and disagreement. By observing that the presence of conflict is salient only if a need for some cooperative order is presumed, I describe how such need is an essential element of politics. I conclude that while politically realistic theories properly acknowledge both conflict and order, other theories ignore, moralize, or abstract them away. ‘Political idealism’ fails to acknowledge conflict and focuses instead on disagreement or reasonable pluralism. Theories can also be flawed if they do not properly recognize the need for order: agonism is an example of this ‘unrealistic realism’. Finally, there are theories that fail to fulfil both criteria: communitarianism is taken as an example of ‘non-political idealism’.

Prossimi eventi

Diventa nostro amico su Facebook

Ricerche e Progetti

logo RGR medio

  • Recuperare la rotta é il titolo del XVIII Rapporto «Giorgio Rota» su Torino, presentato il 7 ottobre alla Biblioteca Nazionale.

lpf logo

  • WP 5/2018 Sud e lotta alla povertà: le esperienze di reddito minimo in Campania e Basilicata

  • Il progetto

rescue logo

logo euvision

Biblioteca F. Guerrini

biblioteca guerrini

 Dotata di oltre 9.000 volumi, offre una documentazione unica in Italia sul pensiero liberale contemporaneo.